I wasn’t sure whether or not I wanted to
see The Hunger Games. Before reading the book I was pretty keen, but once I had
read, and loved, Suzanne Collins’ novel, I was definitely NOT going to see it
and face the same disappointment that I have experienced with almost every
conversion from page to screen. (And yes, this does include Harry Potter, Lord
of the Rings, and Twilight).
However, when I found myself at a loose end
this afternoon, I decided that I’d take the chance and see whether it was worth
it. The answer is definitely yes. The film manages to remain true to the book
without any, or at least not many, deviations from the plot, and where there
are deviations it’s mostly quite easy to understand why they would leave out
certain moments from the book in order to better translate the story to screen.
The problems that I do have with the film stem more from a lack of emphasis on
certain aspects than from an interpretative difference. There could have been
more of a spotlight on the relative poverty of the districts as compared to the
depraved decadence of the Capitol. The role of District 13 in the uprisings
that lead to the formation of the Hunger Games, which is pivotal if they intend
to continue the franchise, was completely omitted. And, as another reviewer
correctly pointed out, Katniss’ deprivations in the arena are glossed over and
played down.
The cast gave me a few moments’ worry, but
seeing especially Woody Harrelson and Josh Hutcherson in their roles relieved
any doubts that I may have had. The casting highlight, for me, was Lenny
Kravitz as Cinna. He plays the role with all the sensitivity that the literary
version of his character portrays, and perfectly captures his unease and
distaste for the proceedings in which he is expected to take part.
Overall, the story remains true to the book
in most of the vital aspects, although the book does provide a deeper and more
complete picture of the history of Panem and the motivations that drive Katniss
in her actions. I will most certainly be adding this to my DVD collection,
though, and am especially keen to see any special features, particularly deleted
scenes.
Geek’s rating: Magrathean
No comments:
Post a Comment